Bekhorot 61 — Exchange of tithe and the agent who erred

Bekhorot 61 ·

How are the conflicting rulings about two tithed animals reconciled, and what happens when an agent makes a mistake while tithing?

One baraita says they graze, following the Rabbis that one does not bring sacrifices into a state of disqualification; one says they are offered, following Rabbi Shimon that one may; and one says they die, following Rabbi Yehuda, who holds a mistake in tithe is an exchange, and an exchange of tithe dies.

Discuss together

How do the three baraitot reflect different views on disqualified sacrifices?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Bekhorot 61

What is the source for one sixtieth?

…small fractions other than 1/60. A very quick analysis: 1/40 and 1/50 in connection to Terumah [Bechorot 61a, Terumot 4:3] According to Beit Hillel (Terumot 4:3), one showing a “good eye,” i.e. a generous person, gives 1/40 of his produce as terumah to the Kohen and a bad-eyed…
Maurice Mizrahi · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive