Berakhot 3 — Watches of the night and a voice in the ruins

Berakhot 3 ·

How does the daf turn a technical question about the hours of the night into a reflection on exile and prayer?

The daf opens by resolving contradictions: two tannaim transmit Rabbi Meir differently, and two transmit Rabbi Eliezer differently, or the first clause of the earlier baraita is not Rabbi Eliezer. Then the Gemara asks what Rabbi Eliezer means by “the end of the first watch.” If the night has three watches, say four hours; if four, say three hours. Why speak of watches at all?

Discuss together

Why does Rabbi Eliezer use “watches” rather than hours?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Berakhot 3

Nefesh, neshama and ruach as words for "soul"

…online source that says the same thing, please let me know. The Maharsha in his Chidushe Aggadot (Berachot 3A, d"h "Mishmorah Rishonah Chamor" ) says almost the exact same thing. He says that there are 3 parts of the soul of man which are called "The Natural", "The Life", and…
Menachem · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive