Gittin 12 — “Work for Me, but I Will Not Feed You”: The Slave’s Maintenance and the Limits of Benefit

Gittin 12 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada recalls learning Gittin at about eighteen, when his teacher raised a sharp difficulty in Tosafot on “his healing belongs to the master.” Tosafot, comparing the mishnah in Ha-Ḥovel, suggest the case of a strong drug; but if the questioner knew that answer, why did he challenge Rabbi Yoḥanan and not the mishnah? The young Ben Yehoyada answered: an Amora’s words are expected to be precise and explanatory, while a tanna speaks more briefly. So the questioner could read the mishnah’s general language narrowly, but not Rabbi Yoḥanan’s unqualified “his healing to his master.” His teacher, he records, was satisfied with the answer.

Discuss together

Why must an earlier tannaitic dispute be checked for transferable reasoning before it serves as precedent?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 12

Can Avodah Zarah acquire a state of Hekdesh?

Rashi in Gittin 12b says Hekdesh can only work on something that is worth a shave Pruta : אין הקדש חל על פחות משוה פרוטה The Ramban argues Hekdesh can work on something worth less than a shave pruta but it needs to be tangeble and worth something: אם היה אותו ממון בעין והקדישו…
user15464 · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive