Gittin 14 — Rules Without Reasons and Agents Under Pressure

Gittin 14 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada asks how Rav Ashi can be challenged with the violent house of Bar Elyashiv, when he himself challenged Amemar from later-born recipients and so must hold that the rule applies in all cases. He answers that Rav Ashi grounds the enactment in what benefits most borrowers, who gain a new loan; violent creditors are rare, so the Sages did not distinguish. Against Amemar, however, later-born recipients are common, so the objection there is decisive.

Discuss together

What does it mean to call a rule “halakha without a reason,” and why might the Sages establish one?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

No related answered record has been identified yet.

Chavruta archive