Gittin 17 — Why a Get Carries a Date: Sister’s Daughter, Fruits, and the Limits of Precision

Gittin 17 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada addresses Rabba bar bar Ḥana’s prayer, “Merciful One, either in Your shadow or in the shadow of the son of Esau,” when the Gemara itself says that Israel could not bear Roman decrees. He answers that for Torah scholars the Persians were harsher, since the angel of Persia asked that the Sages be made liable to the poll tax; but the rule of Esau is nullified wherever “the voice is the voice of Jacob.” Scholars, protected by Torah from Esau, feared Persia more; ordinary people, who lacked that protection, feared Rome more.

Discuss together

How can Persia be both a refuge and a burden, and what does this suggest about reading history in aggada?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 17

Retroactive Get to prevent mamzerut?

…basically, no; there is no way to give a Get now that would have it work back in time. The Talmud Gittin 17a says that a Get must accurately document its date to prevent a man from falsely claiming that he gave it before his adulterous wife (now ex-wife) had relations with…
Shalom · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 3.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive