Gittin 35 — An Oath Too Dangerous to Take: The Widow, the Gold Dinar, and the Vow

Gittin 35 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada asks why the Gemara notes that the story of the gold dinar happened in years of famine. One answer: to show the severity of the oath, since even though she gave the bread as charity in a time when it saved lives, the merit of that commandment did not protect her from the punishment for her oath. Another: only in famine, when flour was very costly, would the flour saved by the dinar’s place count as a real benefit worth a peruta. “Like one who swore truthfully” means she swore inadvertently, not realizing that the saved flour was a benefit to her.

Discuss together

Why did the story of the gold dinar make courts reluctant to impose oaths?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Chavruta archive