Gittin 45 — Captives, Fugitives and Holy Books: Limits Set for the Good of Society

Gittin 45 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada reads Rav Ilish’s surprise at Rav Naḥman’s daughters through the verse “one man in a thousand I found, but a woman among all these I did not find”: it refers to the righteous for whom nature is overturned, like those who stood in fire unharmed, and he thought the daughters who stirred a boiling pot with bare hands were such women. Once he saw them still doing it after their corruption, he concluded it was sorcery from the start. He explains why the raven called first, though Rav Ilish would not trust it: a righteous person’s evil angel too is forced to proclaim good, darkness precedes light as the shell precedes the fruit, and guilt is brought about through the guilty and merit through the meritorious: the raven’s call led the other captive to flee to his death, while Rav Ilish was saved through the dove, the image of the community of Israel. The doubled “Ilish, flee!” is the doubling of a righteous person’s name, a call to run both before and after the river, and a sign that the escape was for him alone. Ben Yehoyada on Gittin 45a · Senlake edition 2019 based on Ben Yehoyada, Jerusalem, 1897

Discuss together

Why does the Gemara finally fine the buyer and not the seller?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 45

May a woman tie tzitzit to be worn by a man?

…invalid: second opinion in Admur; Rama 14/1; Hagahos Maimanis in name of Maharam; Rabbeinu Tam in Gittin 45b, brought in Taz 14/1, Artzos Hachaim 14/1, brought in M”B 14/4; Kesav Sofer 1; Mahrsham 8/7; Daas Torah 14; Meishiv Davar 1/47 He concludes that Practically, we rule like…
mbloch · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive