Gittin 5 — When the Agent Cannot Speak: Later Generations, Decrees, and the Formula of the Sages

Gittin 5 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada, the commentary of Rabbi Yosef Ḥayyim of Baghdad (the Ben Ish Ḥai) on the Talmud, records no comment on Gittin 5a or 5b. His remarks on this tractate are selective and gather around aggadic passages and textual cruxes; the next one is on Gittin 6a. The essence of this daf therefore rests on the Gemara itself. Ben Yehoyada on Gittin 5a–5b: no comment in the edition · Senlake edition 2019 based on Ben Yehoyada, Jerusalem, 1897

Discuss together

How does “after they learned” change the status of the declaration for Rabbah?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 5

Why can't a Tanna write a get?

Well, that's easy: this gemara follows the rather famous opinion of Rabbi Meir ( Gittin 5b , 80a ): אמר רב המנונא משמיה דעולא אומר היה ר"מ כל המשנה [...] בגיטין יוציא והולד ממזר Rav Hamnona said in the name of Ulah: Rabbi Meir used to say "Any mishna [...] in Gittin, she must…
MTL · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 3.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive