Gittin 58 — The Children of Beitar, the Carpenter’s Apprentice and the Laws of Confiscated Land

Gittin 58 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada reads the measures of Beitar as measure for measure: forty se’ahs of tefillin corresponded to the Tablets, which weighed forty se’ahs, for they had slighted the honor of the Torah. The four hundred synagogues, each with four hundred teachers and four hundred children, were built to nullify Esau’s four hundred men, the forces of the other side. Rabbi Yehoshua was sure the child would be a teacher in Israel because, by completing the verse “is it not the Lord, against whom we sinned,” he accepted his suffering as atonement and justified the judgment. Tzafnat’s cry “if You had no pity on us, why not on the holiness of Your mighty Name” refers to the Name through which miracles are done, beyond nature. Ben Yehoyada on Gittin 58a · Senlake edition 2019 based on Ben Yehoyada, Jerusalem, 1897

Discuss together

How does Rabbi Yehoshua recognize a future teacher in the captive boy?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 58

Have there been instances where decisions in the Sanhedrin or Rabbinical decisions concerning Jewish practice have been reversed upon later review?

One example that comes to mind is in Gittin 58b : אמרו הלוקח מן הסיקריקון נותן לבעלים רביע ויד בעלים על העליונה רצו בקרקע נוטלין רצו במעות נוטלין אימתי בזמן שאין בידן ליקח אבל יש בידן ליקח הן קודמין לכל אדם רבי הושיב ב"ד ונמנו שאם שהתה בפני סיקריקון שנים עשר חודש כל הקודם ליקח…
yosefkorn · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive