Gittin 67 — “His Reasoning Is With Him”: Rabbi Yosei, the Sages’ Praises and Kordiakos

Gittin 67 ·

When a husband addresses ten people, how does adding “all of you” change who must be present when one of them writes the get?

Ben Yehoyada explains Isi ben Yehuda’s praises. Rabbi Meir is “wise and a scribe”: a scribe who could write the Torah from memory, two qualities rarely found together, deep reasoning and exact memory. Rabbi Tarfon is “a heap of nuts”: אגוז equals טוב in value, and the Torah is called good; like a nut, its shell must be broken by questions before the fruit is reached. Rabbi Yishmael is “a stocked wine shop”: Torah is likened to wine, which comes in many grades of strength, and his teaching had something for every level.

Discuss together

Why did Rebbi rule like Rabbi Yosei against two other Tannaim?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 67

Bava Kamma 24a: Why is Rabbi Yosei's Analysis sound?

…דר' יוסי נימוקו So, he accredited this argument in BK This argument was already used by Rabbi. Gittin 67a גופא אמר שמואל אמר רבי הלכה כרבי יוסי דאמר מילי לא מימסרן לשליח אמר לפניו ר"ש ברבי מאחר שר"מ וחנינא איש אונו חולקין על רבי יוסי מה ראה רבי לומר הלכה כר' יוסי אמר לו שתוק בני…
kouty · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive