Gittin 7 — Silence, Mourning, and a Ship at Sea: From Aggada Back to the Map

Gittin 7 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada reads Mar Ukva’s correspondence closely. The first question, whether he may hand his tormentors to the government, was sent in writing because it was sensitive, and Rabbi Elazar answered in writing with a verse of restraint; the second, a complaint that they trouble him greatly, was sent orally, and Rabbi Elazar answered orally. That is why the Gemara stresses that “the word went out from the mouth of Rabbi Elazar”: a spoken word had effect. He explains “rise early and stay late against them” as learning under strain, which earns reward even in this world, and “they will perish by themselves” as a way of ensuring that no one is punished through Mar Ukva himself. He also calls ever min ha-ḥai a “great thing” because, following earlier authorities, eating it violates both a negative command and the positive command of slaughter.

Discuss together

How do the teachings about fear in the home and about Mar Ukva treat the power of speech?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Gittin 7

Is God a kosher witness?

…Additionally the death of Moshe was announced and the Mishna says in Gittin See Tosfot Yom Tov Gittin 7, 4 ועדים לשון עדות בעלמא הוא. כמ"ש במשנה ב' פרק בתרא דיבמות וריש פ"י שם. וכן במשנה ט' פרק ב' דכתובות
kouty · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive