Gittin 88 — “And You Shall Have Grown Old in the Land”: Signatures, Exile and the Coerced Get

Gittin 88 ·

How does the Mishnah distinguish between a get compelled by a gentile court on its own authority and one in which gentile officials carry out a Jewish court's ruling?

Ben Yehoyada asks why the exile of the ten tribes is tied to not making the pilgrimage, a mere positive commandment, rather than to the idolatry that was common. He explains that there were righteous people among them who did not worship idols, whose merit might have averted the exile, as with Sodom; but even they did not go up to the festivals after Hoshea removed the guards, so the decree rested on them too. Tu B’Av was made a festival in Jerusalem, hoping the pilgrimage would resume, while the evil fell on the ten tribes who did not respond. On “craftsman and locksmith” he adds: when the Sages open a matter to permit, purify or acquit, no one can contradict them; when they close it, no one can reopen it. Ben Yehoyada on Gittin 88a · Senlake edition 2019 based on Ben Yehoyada, Jerusalem, 1897

Discuss together

Why does the Gemara tie the exile to not going up on the festivals?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Chavruta archive