Kiddushin 29 — What a Father Owes His Son

Kiddushin 29 ·

If a father and his son cannot both go away to study Torah, how does Rabbi Yehudah decide whose learning takes precedence?

On Rav Aḥa bar Ya'akov's words "I am better than you," Ben Yehoyada distinguishes two kinds of study: first, mastery of the texts, best learned from one teacher, and then analysis and reasoning, best learned in a great academy among many scholars. Both father and son had mastered the texts; one had to stay home for the family's livelihood. When the father saw his son was not sharp even after time with Abaye, he concluded his own sharper mind would bear more fruit there. On Abaye's instruction not to host him, he answers the Maharsha: Abaye was sure Rav Aḥa would be saved and asked only whether the rescue would be a public miracle that kills the demon for everyone, rather than a private escape that leaves it in place.

Discuss together

Why does the Temple bear no loss when prices change, while a private seller relies on "He who exacted payment"?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Kiddushin 29

Is a "shaliach" required to perform a brit milah?

The Talmud ( Kiddushin 29a ) states the following: למולו מנלן דכתיב וימל אברהם את יצחק בנו והיכא דלא מהליה אבוה מיחייבי בי דינא למימהליה דכתיב המול לכם כל זכר והיכא דלא מהליה בי דינא מיחייב איהו למימהל נפשיה דכתיב וערל זכר אשר לא ימול את בשר ערלתו ונכרתה ‘To circumcise him.’ How…
Alex · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive