Kiddushin 32 — Who Pays, How to Correct, and Who May Waive Honor

Kiddushin 32 ·

If a father asks his son for water just as another mitzvah needs doing, why does Isi ben Yehudah ask whether someone else can perform that mitzvah?

On Rabban Gamliel serving drinks, Ben Yehoyada asks why Rabbi Eliezer could refuse the cup, given the rule that one does not refuse a greater person and that a host's word should be obeyed. He answers that refusing out of respect for the host's own honor is not the kind of refusal those rules forbid. On Rabbi Tzadok's list, "He makes the winds blow, raises clouds, brings rain," he notes that dew is omitted because it falls unseen at night, while the others are visible to all.

Discuss together

Why does it matter whether the cost of honoring parents comes from the father or the son?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Kiddushin 32

Who are the Elders in the beginning of Avot

…and on whom it says "Now Eli was very old". 1 The elders' greatness was that they were wise ( Kiddushin 32b ), and they were, well, elders - they were the elders of the tribes and evidently they were considered to be respected individuals (in Bamidbar 11:16 they are described as…
Harel13 · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive