Kiddushin 33 — Rising Before Sages, Elders, and a Torah Scroll

Kiddushin 33 ·

What did Rabbi Yochanan see in the life experience of elderly non-Jews that led him to rise in their presence?

Ben Yehoyada questions Rashi's explanation of "you will cause them to stumble in the future": would the pilgrims stop bringing first fruits merely because no one rose for them? He notes that they knew craftsmen did not rise even for scholars. On Rav Naḥman's "how many Naḥman bar Abba are in the market," he observes that Rav Naḥman's father was named Ya'akov, so "bar Abba" is a modest title of importance, as in "he made me a father to Pharaoh": the honor shown me is for the Torah, not my lineage.

Discuss together

Why may craftsmen not stop work to stand before scholars, yet stand for those bringing first fruits?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Chavruta archive