Kiddushin 4 — Leaving Without Money, and Testing Every Inference

Kiddushin 4 ·

Why does the Torah need separate sources for a father's right to his daughter's earnings and his right to her betrothal money?

Ben Yehoyada writes no comment on Kiddushin 4. His commentary on this tractate addresses only selected, mostly aggadic passages, and neither 4a nor 4b is among them in the Senlake edition. The nearest comments are on Kiddushin 2 and Kiddushin 13.

Discuss together

In what sense does a betrothed daughter "leave" her father, and why is that enough for the analogy to the maidservant?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Kiddushin 4

Does marrying the woman one got pregnant before the baby is born make a difference?

…understood after learning several Mishnayot Ketubbot 1, 9 and a Mishna in Baba Batra 8, 5 and Kiddushin 4, 8 . See Gemara Kidushin 74a: אמר רב נחמן: שלשה נאמנין על הבכור, אלו הן: חיה, אביו, ואמו . &rml Rav Nahman said: Three are believed with respect to a first-born. These are…
miyodeya · CC BY-SA 3.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive