Kiddushin 9 — "Give, Give," the Document, and the Verse for Intercourse

Kiddushin 9 ·

Why does Reish Lakish compare a betrothal document to both a get and money when asking whether it must be written specifically for this woman?

Ben Yehoyada writes no comment on Kiddushin 9. His commentary on this tractate addresses only selected, mostly aggadic passages, and neither 9a nor 9b is among them in the Senlake edition. The nearest comments are on Kiddushin 2 and Kiddushin 13.

Discuss together

Why does "give, give" not count as acceptance, and why is even a single "give" rejected in the halakha?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Cites this daf · Kiddushin 9

Deriving *halachah* from the books of the Prophets

…תוס' (ע"ז כ"ב ע"ב) ד"ה תיפוק לי' דכ' כיון דאבילות אין לו סמך בד"ת רק בקבלה הקלו בו, ועי' תוספות (קידושין ט' ע"א) ד"ה הלכתא דכ' כיון דאין למוד זה רק מד"ק לא שייך להקשות הלכתא למ"ל. The Ramban in Sefer Ha-Mitzvot (shoresh 2) explains that since Nevi'im cannot create new laws, the…
wfb · miyodeya · CC BY-SA 4.0

Full question and answer · Original source

Chavruta archive