Gittin 56 — Kamtza and Bar Kamtza: How Jerusalem Fell and What Was Saved

Gittin 56 ·

How does the argument develop across both sides of this daf?

Ben Yehoyada reads the details of the story as signs from Heaven. Bar Kamtza assumed the Sages saw and approved, though they did not see him take the man by the hand. The Caesar sent a calf, recalling that every reckoning carries part of the sin of the golden calf, and the blemish fell on the lips, pointing to evil speech, the sin of the Second Temple, which weighs like the three gravest sins and therefore brought three years of siege and hunger. Rabbi Zekharya’s “humility” was that he would not decide by his own view but sent the matter to the Sanhedrin, and meanwhile the calf left the Temple court and the chance was lost. Nero’s arrows fell on Jerusalem against nature; because he honored a verse and withdrew from destroying the light of the world, Rabbi Meir, who “lit up” the eyes of the Sages, came from him. Rabbi Tzadok fasted forty years, a year for each day of the journey across the Land, as with the spies.

Discuss together

Why does the Gemara hold the silent Rabbis partly responsible for Bar Kamtza’s revenge?

Read the sources

Full shiur · Shiur source sheet

From the library

Chavruta archive